Monday, December 3, 2018

Marilyn Monroe: the Life, the Death, and the Mystery by Macey Sheldon

         How could a radiant Hollywood scarlet take her own life, a doctor with too much to lose cover it up, or a picture perfect family be behind it all? On August 5, 1962, in the time of hazy glamour, Marilyn Monroe was pronounced dead. The adored Golden Age bombshell was gone, but what happened? There was speculation Marilyn took her own life. But, why would someone with so much to live for kill themselves? Could the government have been involved? Behind the blinding smiles could there be monsters? Or could medical malpractice be at work? Could just one mistake have brought Monroe’s demise? Let’s evaluate a few of these theories, and try to figure out what really happened to Ms. Monroe that fateful day.
            Marilyn Monroe was the epitome of Hollywood glamour. With coiffed platinum curls, a classic red lip, and stunning blue bedroom eyes, she truly was stunning. Though it was that beauty that got her into some difficult situations. Even now about 55 years since her passing rumors still hang around her past self. Many of those whispers regarding alleged affairs with two of the Kennedy brothers, one of which being the 35th president of the United States (“PEOPLE Explains: All About Marilyn Monroe's Alleged Affairs with JFK and Brother Bobby”). Still, all the same, it was that pretty face that started her career and is what cemented her legacy. Fellow screen siren Elizabeth Taylor illustrated, “She seemed to have a kind of unconscious glow about her physical self that was innocent, like a child” (“Said About Marilyn Monroe”). She was lovely on the outside, but her spirit was what really set her apart.
            Marilyn was extremely insecure. Yes, the famously gorgeous actress was extremely self-conscious! This showed the single crack in her polished veneer. It led way to her past self, Norma Jeane Baker, an orphaned child who married at the innocent age of 16 to get out of a life in the system (Kashner). Marilyn recounts of her short-lived marriage to James Dougherty, the first of three, in one of her many diaries, “My relationship with him was basically insecure from the first night I spent alone with him” (Kashner). This was presumed to be written just about a year after she was first married to him. Later in her personal journal, she writes of how she thinks she can’t live up to the past glory of Dougherty’s past girlfriend, a Santa Barbara beauty queen:
            “Finding myself offhandedly stood up snubbed my first feeling was not of anger—but the numb pain of rejection & hurt at the destruction of some sort of idealistic image of true love. My first impulse then was one of complete subjection humiliation, alonement to the male counterpart. (all this thought & writing has made my hands tremble …)”. (Kashner)
She always struggled with the idea that she was not good enough for people’s approval, even far into her successful career (Kashner). She frequently wrote in her diary the heartbreaking repetitive phrase “Alone!!!!!!! I am alone I am always alone no matter what” (Kashner).
            One of Marilyn’s lesser-known qualities is that she was actually extremely intelligent. Sam Shaw, a close friend of Monroe and legendary photographer, once described her as, “Always joyful, witty, fun loving, and serious about acting with a terrific desire to learn, to know about the arts, the theatre, her craft, to read good books, to read poetry and try to reach ecstasy of poetic thoughts.” (“Said About Marilyn Monroe”) Though many thought of her as just a “dumb blonde” she was actually an impassioned poet who loved to read (Kashner). She had a knack for collecting books, pretty much any that piqued her ever-inquiring mind. Her personal library contained more than 400 books in varying subjects including psychology, philosophy, history, politics, and biographies; many of them first editions (Marilyn Timeline). They were much more than just trophies on a shelf for her; they were her lifeline. Books brought her back down to earth and kept her company during her bouts of insomnia, which most likely stemmed from her time in foster care (Kashner). It is clear how well read Marilyn was by the eloquence with which she spoke.
            Marilyn Monroe took her job extremely seriously. She worked hard at her craft, continually trying to be the best, and always trying to get new job opportunities. Joshua Logan, director of Bus Stop, said:
            Marilyn is as near a genius as any actress I ever knew. She is an artist beyond artistry. She is the most completely realized and authentic film actress since Garbo. She has that same                    unfathomable mysteriousness. She is pure cinema. (“Said About Marilyn Monroe”)
She is best known for her roles in All About Eve, Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, and of course The Seven Year Itch. In Bus Stop Marilyn proved to critics that she could switch things up from her usual role, and play a straight dramatic role. In 1960, Marilyn Monroe showed just how all her hard work paid off when she won a Golden Globe for her performance in Some Like It Hot (Biography). It is a tragedy that just as Marilyn’s career was starting to pick up speed, she passed away.
            Though Monroe had a hard time loving herself, she took all that misplaced love and sent it out into the world. Beneath all the glitz and glamour that was Marilyn Monroe, was a compassionate human being who loved all living things. Throughout her life, she donated time and money to charitable causes. For example in the St. Jude’s Children’s Hospital, Miss Monroe headlined the event and performed a song from Gentlemen Prefer Blondes. She even donated her earrings from the world premiere of The Prince and The Showgirl to the milk fund for babies in need! Ella Fitzgerald once said:
           “I owe Marilyn Monroe a real debt…she personally called the owner of the Mocamba  and told him she wanted me booked immediately, and if he would do it, she would take  the front table every night. She told him-and it was true, due to Marilyn’s superstar status that the press would go wild. The owner said yes, and Marilyn was there, front table, every night. The press went overboard. After that, I never had to play at a small jazz club again. She was an unusual woman—a little ahead of her times. And she didn’t know it.” (Marilyn Timeline)
 In this way, we are able to see the person behind the beautiful enigma that is Marilyn Monroe.
            The death of Marilyn Monroe still holds as much mystery as it did almost 55 years ago. For a girl whose life was filled with passing rumors, it is only fitting that her death has just the same. But, behind every lie, there must lay a glimmer of truth, and today we just may be able to find that truth. The three main conspiracies that have held the test of time surrounding this starlet’s demise are: Marilyn committed suicide by overdosing, the government surrounding JFK murdered Marilyn and staged it as a suicide, or lastly that medical malpractice was at work and it all was just an accident. Look closely; we might be able to solve the death of Marilyn Monroe.
            The first and most readily accepted theory is that Marilyn committed suicide. Marilyn Monroe was severely depressed, and after a long battle with it, took her own life. The last few hours before her ultimate death went like this. At 8:00 p.m., August 4th, Dr. Greenson—remember that name—Marilyn’s psychiatrist was getting ready to leave her house (Markel). Dr. Ralph Greenson frequently used this unorthodox, and now very discredited, therapy known as adoption therapy where he would either come to her home or her to his. It is also believed that Dr. Greenson was one of Marilyn’s lovers, and used this time for more than just counseling (Kashner). All the same, before he left, he asked Eunice Murray, Marilyn’s live-in housekeeper, to keep a close eye on the famous bombshell. Whether it had been because she was going through a depressive episode or because of something else, the world may never know (Markel). At this same time, Marilyn headed to sleep for the night. She is then thought to have engaged in her nightly routine of popping a sleeping pill and washing it all down with a flute of champagne. It was then at around 3:25 a.m. August 6, that Mrs. Murray looked through Marilyn’s French doors and discovered an unusually limp Monroe. Murray recalled of that night, “(Marilyn) looked peculiar.”(Markel) She immediately called Dr. Greenson back to the house who, upon arrival, broke through the glass door, and realized Marilyn was gone (Markel). All that was left was a naked body—with one hand clutching a telephone and the other hanging off the bed—and an empty pill bottle balanced on the star’s nightstand (“From the Archives: Marilyn Monroe Dies; Pills Blamed.”). Not too long after did Dr. Hyam Engelberg—also remember him—Marilyn’s personal physician, a.k.a. the man who prescribed those life-ending pills just three days prior, arrives at the scene. Fifty Nembutal capsules were found missing and is what led coroners to mark her death down as a suicide (“From the Archives: Marilyn Monroe Dies; Pills Blamed.”). Any barbiturate mixed with alcohol creates a lethal cocktail, which is why either accidental or intentional, the death of Ms. Marilyn Monroe is suspected to be a suicidal overdose (“Nembutal: Indications, Side Effects, Warnings.”). Along with the fact that Monroe was known to be depressed, and had dealt with years of abuse, this theory is the most plausible of all.
            The second most popular theory surrounding Marilyn’s death is that the government, more precisely the Kennedy’s, had something to do with her death. Though it was never proven that there were any sort of affairs with John F. Kennedy (J.F.K) or his brother Robert F. Kennedy, pictures speak a thousand words, and one look at her sultry “Happy Birthday” performance just months before her death, is enough for most to believe (“Marilyn's Last Day: Twenty-Four Hours In the Death of a Legend.”). Marilyn’s biographer, James Spada, said, “it was pretty clear that Marilyn had had sexual relations with both Bobby and Jack” (“PEOPLE Explains: All About Marilyn Monroe's Alleged Affairs with JFK and Brother Bobby.”). They might have had romantic relations, so what? Well, shortly after the investigation, many government employed people who were involved were later given high-profile new jobs. Perhaps an incentive to keep quiet? (“Marilyn's Last Day: Twenty-Four Hours In the Death of a Legend.”). One strong believer that the Kennedy’s were behind this murder was Monroe’s second husband, Joe DiMaggio. He insisted for years, “I always knew who killed her, but I didn’t want to start a revolution in this country. She told me someone would do her in, but I kept quiet” (“PEOPLE Explains: All About Marilyn Monroe's Alleged Affairs with JFK and Brother Bobby.”). Even eerier, this is not the first time Marilyn had confided that someone in the government might be out to get her. In her personal journal, she wrote about JFK’s brother-in-law Peter Lawford saying, “Peter He Might Harm Me, Poison Me.” (Kashner) This note is believed to have been written around 1956. For her to be poisoned a couple of years later, under suspicious circumstances, seems strange to say the least. Could it have been prophecy or all just a coincidence? Though this theory does not have as much evidence as the first, it does still have substance and to this day is the most well-believed conspiracy theory surrounding Marilyn Monroe’s death.
            The final theory is that Marilyn died as a result of medical malpractice. The two doctors in question are Dr. Ralph Greenson and Dr. Hyam Engelburg. As reported earlier, Dr. Greenson was Marilyn’s psychiatrist, and Dr. Engleburg was Marilyn’s personal physician. As with most psychiatrists of this period, Dr. Greenson pushed drugs onto Marilyn. The man himself once said of Monroe, “Give her something of me to swallow, to take in, so that she could overcome the sense of terrible emptiness that would depress and infuriate her” (Turner). As with Dr. Engelburg, not only was he the person to prescribe the medication that theoretically killed her, he was also the person who called the police. ”Marilyn Monroe has died. She's committed suicide," the doctor reported at 4:25 a.m. on Aug. 5, 1962, in a phone call to the Los Angeles Police Department. "I'm Dr. Hyman Engelberg, Marilyn Monroe's physician. I'm at her residence. She's committed suicide” (Oliver). All of this is pretty convenient, one doctor who pushes drugs, another who writes the prescription, and both end up at the scene of the crime together with just enough time to do something before the police arrive. A key factor to look at is that Marilyn had 15 other bottles of medicine on her nightstand, and the only one that was empty was the one that Dr. Engelburg later falsely claimed he had never prescribed (Creighton). Could the doctors have figured out that they had essentially poisoned Marilyn, and quickly staged it all as a suicide to avoid the revoking of their medical licenses? Or could it have been planned, and that instead of overdosing on just one type of pill, Marilyn simply followed doctors orders and taken what she was told, while later the single pill bottle was emptied? Due to a lack of substantial evidence, either theory is plausible; however, neither have even documentation or data.
            So what really happened? There are countless possibilities and small details to look into, however seeing as this death took place over half a decade ago, it would be nearly impossible to dig up the absolute truth. In a locally run survey, 57.6 percent of people believe Marilyn Monroe committed suicide; 30.3 percent believe the government was somehow involved, and 12.1 percent believe her doctors were the ones at fault. Throughout the years, key witnesses from that night—friends, her psychiatrist, her press agent, an attorney, and the police—have tweaked their stories, and all of them are filled with contradictions (“Marilyn's Last Day: Twenty-Four Hours In the Death of a Legend.”). This case may have been closed as a “Possible Suicide,” however the truth is still out there waiting to be discovered.
            Marilyn Monroe led a scandalous life, which was ended in mystery. After her ultimate departure, three conspiracy theories emerged: she committed suicide, she was the victim of medical malpractice, or she was taken out by the government. Unfortunately, because so much time has passed, we may never know what happened that fateful day. The mystery lives on and just might stay that way for the rest of time. Until the absolute truth comes out, we should all remember her as the scarlet who left a lasting legacy, instead of just a girl marked as a “Probable Suicide.”

                                                                        Works Cited
 “Biography.” IMDb, IMDb.com, www.imdb.com/name/nm0000054/bio?ref_=nm_ql_1.                         (Biography)
Creighton, Sam. “Marilyn Monroe Died as Result of 'Medical Negligence' .” Daily Mail               Online, Associated Newspapers, 13 May 2015, www.dailymail.co.uk/news/                                    article-3080063/Marilyn-Monroe-died-result-medical-negligence.html. (Creighton)
 “From the Archives: Marilyn Monroe Dies; Pills Blamed.” Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles                     Times, 6 Aug. 1962, www.latimes.com/local/obituaries/archives/la-me-marilyn-                           monroe-19620806-story.html. (“From the Archives: Marilyn Monroe Dies; Pills                           Blamed.”)
Kashner, Sam. “Marilyn and Her Monsters.” Vanity Fair, Vanity Fair, 17 Nov. 2017,                                www.vanityfair.com/culture/2010/11/marilyn-monroe-201011. (Kashner)
 “Marilyn's Last Day: Twenty-Four Hours Inthe Death of a Legend.” The Independent,                             Independent Digital News and Media, 23 Oct. 2011, www.independent.co.uk/news/                      world/americas/marilyns-last-day-twenty-four-hours-inthe-death-of-a-                                           legend-422034.html. (“Marilyn's Last Day: Twenty-Four Hours Inthe Death of a                           Legend.”)
Marilyn Timeline See All, marilynmonroe.com/about/see-all/. (Marilyn Timeline)
Markel, Dr. Howard. “Column: Marilyn Monroe and the Prescription Drugs That Killed Her.”                 PBS, Public Broadcasting Service, 5 Aug. 2016, www.pbs.org/newshour/health/marilyn-           monroe-and-the-prescription-drugs-that-killed-her. (Markel)
 “Nembutal: Indications, Side Effects, Warnings.” Drugs.com, Drugs.com, www.drugs.com/cdi/             nembutal.html. (“Nembutal: Indications, Side Effects, Warnings.”)
S Oliver, Myrna | Times Staff Writer. “Dr. Hyman Engelberg, 92; Marilyn Monroe's Personal                     Physician.” Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles Times, 21 Dec. 2005,                                                articles.latimes.com/2005/dec/21/local/me-engelberg21. (Oliver)
 “PEOPLE Explains: All About Marilyn Monroe's Alleged Affairs with JFK and Brother              Bobby.” PEOPLE.com, people.com/politics/marilyn-monroe-affair-john-f-kennedy-                         robert-f-kennedy/. (“PEOPLE Explains: All About Marilyn Monroe's Alleged Affairs             with JFK and Brother Bobby.”)
“Said About Marilyn Monroe.” Retrorambling, 19 Feb. 2011, retrorambling.wordpress.com/                     articles/tinsle-town-royalties/said-about-marilyn-monroe/. (“Said About Marilyn                           Monroe”)
Turner, Christopher. “Marilyn Monroe on the Couch.” The Telegraph, Telegraph Media Group, 23 June 2010, www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/film/7843140/Marilyn-Monroe-on-the-                      couch.html. (Turner)


No comments:

Post a Comment